So my grandpa flipped out and declared that this all may be illegal and send me to prison for life ._>
can someone explain to me the legality standpoint of brawl "hacking"?
I don't think it's illegal because we are editing our own property. Once we purchase the game, we are free to do with it as we please, like break the game disc. Granted why you would buy a game just to break it is beyond me but it proves the point. We aren't causing any harm just editing stuff in the game. If this was illegal, the creators of Gamesharks, Action Replays, and Game Genies would be sued immensely.
I think of it as:
"Hey, we bought the game, so we have the right to do what the heck we want with it."
You dont buy a cheeseburger, and the person selling it cant say you cant put ketchup on it.
On the other hand we are modifying and distributing files created by Nintendo. <.< Which is illegal.
But if they minded, they would have taken action by now.
Quote from: ds22 on July 01, 2010, 12:17:21 AM
But if they minded, they would have taken action by now.
Didn't they threaten Syntax Error back in the early days. Hence the reason they died off.
It's modifying copyrighted files, which is technically illegal, but isn't wrong. Also, I extremely doubt that anybody would bother prosecuting a Brawl hacker over the millions of other hackers , especially pirates (piracy actually IS stealing, we're just messing with stuff we bought). In the end, we're not harming Nintendo in any way, in fact, we're probably encouraging people to buy Brawl so they can hack it.
Quote from: BeyondYou on July 01, 2010, 12:19:06 AM
Quote from: ds22 on July 01, 2010, 12:17:21 AM
But if they minded, they would have taken action by now.
Didn't they threaten Syntax Error back in the early days. Hence the reason they died off.
Nobody's gotten in trouble for Brawl hacking (Syntax Error got shut down by Wordpress, NOT Nintendo). Wordpress was afraid that Nintendo would do something, but we don't even know if Nintendo knew about them then or now. We do know however that they haven't tried to stop us specifically (they've tried to stop Homebrew in general, but that's because of piracy).
I agree with STUFF2o. But it really depends on how you look at it.
Anyways, your grandpa is old and shouldn't be questioning the legality of hacking brawl. If you get sent to prison I'll go there right along with you man.
And I'll you a cake with a file in it.
Just say your Grandpa that he is wrong and that you have our comments as prove.
its illegal if u sell hacked brawl, cuz that wuld be selling modified copyrighted material
Oh, you silly old people and your pretend "knowledge" of technology.
:af: i can't wait to meet beyondyou in jail and eat lots of cake
Anybody who thinks it's a good idea to arrest a Brawl hacker is an imbecile. They could be spending their time arresting people who actually hurt people in some way. Thankfully, I don't know of anybody that stupid.
You never know STUFF2o, there's alot of stupid people out there.
is it illegal, doubt it. If it is who cares, im still doing it. Nintendo wont take action. :af:
Quote from: ShadowSnake on July 05, 2010, 07:56:19 AM
is it illegal, doubt it. If it is who cares, im still doing it. Nintendo wont take action. :af:
XD
:af:
I think nintendo should see what we do....so they'll know what we want and thus they could sell more games....^^
But it's just my opinion....(I know it is kinda stupid)
Quote from: Micaiah91 on July 05, 2010, 08:13:26 AM
Quote from: ShadowSnake on July 05, 2010, 07:56:19 AM
is it illegal, doubt it. If it is who cares, im still doing it. Nintendo wont take action. :af:
XD
:af:
I think nintendo should see what we do....so they'll know what we want and thus they could sell more games....^^
But it's just my opinion....(I know it is kinda stupid)
Its kinda funny how were getting to make games just as good as they can (or better). Mewtwo2000's stages, mariokart64n's models, johnlcb's textures, etc.
Quote from: ShadowSnake on July 05, 2010, 08:19:36 AM
Quote from: Micaiah91 on July 05, 2010, 08:13:26 AM
Quote from: ShadowSnake on July 05, 2010, 07:56:19 AM
is it illegal, doubt it. If it is who cares, im still doing it. Nintendo wont take action. :af:
XD
:af:
I think nintendo should see what we do....so they'll know what we want and thus they could sell more games....^^
But it's just my opinion....(I know it is kinda stupid)
Its kinda funny how were getting to make games just as good as they can (or better). Mewtwo2000's stages, mariokart64n's models, johnlcb's textures, etc.
The only think that they got is experience.....
Quote from: Micaiah91 on July 05, 2010, 08:26:48 AM
The only think that they got is experience.....
Exactly, they just have used more time and had better resources.
10 years game college = 1 year hack college
Quote from: ShadowSnake on July 05, 2010, 08:35:37 AM
Quote from: Micaiah91 on July 05, 2010, 08:26:48 AM
The only think that they got is experience.....
Exactly, they just have used more time and had better resources.
10 years game college = 1 year hack college
XD
I would really love to go to a game college :happy:
I would like to take hacking classes in highschool(starting this year)/college
btw to all who mentioned my grampa being old/wrong he got mad and sed "suck it"
He complains about this being legal or not and he later says that. One hell of a papi you have there.
i think its only illegal with you download the game without buying it and/or mod it or the system then trying to sell it
or is it?
if this is illegal i might stop
THis is legal were editing stuff not selling.
Why does nintendo hate hackers hacks is what makes ssbb so awesome ultimant customaazation thus MUGEN 2.
It's definitely illegal to distribute hacks for money, but I'm not sure about what we do here. In any case, there's no way you'd get sent to jail for distributing intellectual property. Just sued/fined (not that that'll happen either).
Buying the game to play it != buying a license to modify its content.
It's illegal, don't kid yourselves with your childish naïveté. Fortunately for us, it probably makes Nintendo more money, so they leave us alone.
Action Replay and its ilk work by modifying RAM, not by directly altering proprietary files like we do.
Quote from: Micaiah91 on July 05, 2010, 08:13:26 AM
Quote from: ShadowSnake on July 05, 2010, 07:56:19 AM
is it illegal, doubt it. If it is who cares, im still doing it. Nintendo wont take action. :af:
XD
:af:
I think nintendo should see what we do....so they'll know what we want and thus they could sell more games....^^
But it's just my opinion....(I know it is kinda stupid)
You has made my brain have an idea...Ima send pics of hacked characters, stages, etc to IGN's Chris HArris telling him that its fan art and we'll see if he publishes them somewhere xDDDDD
Quote from: LordNOaH on July 08, 2010, 04:05:59 PM
Quote from: Micaiah91 on July 05, 2010, 08:13:26 AM
Quote from: ShadowSnake on July 05, 2010, 07:56:19 AM
is it illegal, doubt it. If it is who cares, im still doing it. Nintendo wont take action. :af:
XD
:af:
I think nintendo should see what we do....so they'll know what we want and thus they could sell more games....^^
But it's just my opinion....(I know it is kinda stupid)
You has made my brain have an idea...Ima send pics of hacked characters, stages, etc to IGN's Chris HArris telling him that its fan art and we'll see if he publishes them somewhere xDDDDD
They'd believe it because you know what they say "You can't spell ignorant without IGN!"
Vyse think how would they make it so pokemon have 999 of every stat.
THey definitely have to modify it to make the stats 999.
it would be illegal if we sold our edited material.
Quote from: fireking220 on July 08, 2010, 05:33:29 PM
it would be illegal if we sold our edited material.
Quote from: Vyse on July 08, 2010, 04:01:11 PM
Buying the game to play it != buying a license to modify its content.
It's illegal, don't kid yourselves with your childish naïveté. Fortunately for us, it probably makes Nintendo more money, so they leave us alone.
Action Replay and its ilk work by modifying RAM, not by directly altering proprietary files like we do.
...
Quote from: ADJSonic on July 08, 2010, 04:31:27 PM
Vyse think how would they make it so pokemon have 999 of every stat.
THey definitely have to modify it to make the stats 999.
I'm guessing you don't actually know anything about how ARs work.
It's still memory modification, not changing any of the game's internal files.
Oh....
Well, here's how I stand on this. It may me illegal, it may not, I don't know. But, if you think that nintendo cares, they would've followed suit, and they haven't. And they won't, nintendo probably knows that with the whole viacom and youtube, people have most likely stopped buying there products. And, that the same would happen with nintendo. If they sued, nobody would but there games anymore. I mean, they hate it when people post ROMs of their games, yet they haven't filed suit. Why? Cause nintendo knows they would lose a lot of fans if they followed suit. So I don't think nintendo really cares about us hacking. So let's keep hacking!!!!!!!!!
Quote from: NecroMasterX on July 08, 2010, 09:05:24 PM
Well, here's how I stand on this. It may me illegal, it may not, I don't know. But, if you think that nintendo cares, they would've followed suit, and they haven't. And they won't, nintendo probably knows that with the whole viacom and youtube, people have most likely stopped buying there products. And, that the same would happen with nintendo. If they sued, nobody would but there games anymore. I mean, they hate it when people post ROMs of their games, yet they haven't filed suit. Why? Cause nintendo knows they would lose a lot of fans if they followed suit. So I don't think nintendo really cares about us hacking. So let's keep hacking!!!!!!!!!
Exactly, i agree with NMX.
Whether Nintendo cares or not has nothing to do with legality.
We decrypt and modify Nintendo's proprietary files using programs from or based on the proprietary Nintendo Revolution Software Development Kit without permission from Nintendo. What we are doing is illegal; there's no way around it.
But unless Nintendo presses charges -- and they won't do that, because they don't care -- we won't get in trouble for it.
Nintendo seems to only care about pirating at this time. but who knows, if their "family"console starts getting nude hacks.. the winds may change on us.
but otherwise what we are doing is 100% ILLEGAL, ..but nintendo can't sue you all for downloading mods here.
they would only attack the forum owner to cease operation of the site. worst case scenario, they may demand the SQL database of this forum. which would hand them over our IPs and emails... but they would have to pull jack into a court battle for that.. highly unlikely..
but no where in the history of videogame modding, has any company sued individual members of a hacking or warez site.
so users on the forum are 100% safe, the staff here on the other hand are not.
Conclusion:
Illegal: Yes
Risk: Low
Quote from: mariokart64n on July 09, 2010, 02:08:12 AM
Nintendo seems to only care about pirating at this time. but who knows, if their "family"console starts getting nude hacks.. the winds may change on us...
Conclusion:
Illegal: Yes
Risk: Slim to none
Nude hacks: Yep I've seen tons of 'em, here and elsewhere. :>.>palm:
btw fixed the risk level :af:
Who cares if it's illeagel, nintendo won't do anything and we know it.
Quote from: mariokart64n on July 09, 2010, 02:08:12 AM
Nintendo seems to only care about pirating at this time. but who knows, if their "family"console starts getting nude hacks.. the winds may change on us.
but otherwise what we are doing is 100% ILLEGAL, ..but nintendo can't sue you all for downloading mods here.
they would only attack the forum owner to cease operation of the site. worst case scenario, they may demand the SQL database of this forum. which would hand them over our IPs and emails... but they would have to pull jack into a court battle for that.. highly unlikely..
but no where in the history of videogame modding, has any company sued individual members of a hacking or warez site.
so users on the forum are 100% safe, the staff here on the other hand are not.
Conclusion:
Illegal: Yes
Risk: Low
lol imagines us all in court being sued by nintendo, but anyway i think this is illegal but definitely not wrong they don't go after pirates why would they go after hackers just trying to make their game better
Quote from: Dirtboy345 on July 09, 2010, 04:47:04 AM
Quote from: mariokart64n on July 09, 2010, 02:08:12 AM
Nintendo seems to only care about pirating at this time. but who knows, if their "family"console starts getting nude hacks.. the winds may change on us.
but otherwise what we are doing is 100% ILLEGAL, ..but nintendo can't sue you all for downloading mods here.
they would only attack the forum owner to cease operation of the site. worst case scenario, they may demand the SQL database of this forum. which would hand them over our IPs and emails... but they would have to pull jack into a court battle for that.. highly unlikely..
but no where in the history of videogame modding, has any company sued individual members of a hacking or warez site.
so users on the forum are 100% safe, the staff here on the other hand are not.
Conclusion:
Illegal: Yes
Risk: Low
lol imagines us all in court being sued by nintendo, but anyway i think this is illegal but definitely not wrong they don't go after pirates why would they go after hackers just trying to make their game better
ha just imagine us all in the courts... "Jack Harvest, would you like to call someone to the stand?" "Yes, i call BeyondYou to the stand" that would one awkward day, lol.
they actually have sued mod chip makers, and have gone after alot of homebrew makers. typically who have created debuggers for cheating, and playing backups.
I haven't heard of a case where nintendo has attacked a warez share site, but nintendo has taken legal action over the wii..
just saying, nobody can say what nintendo will, and won't do.
Nintendo has better things to do than sue a bunch of teens and young adults with no money.
Think of it as that.
I'm only 11
...You don't really think they sue to actually get money out of these people, right?
Nintendo doesn't want your money; there's no way a normal person could ever pay the amounts they ask for. They sue to make an example of you and to make you stop whatever it is you're doing.
Who knows?
They could just fine us of leave us alone for all they care.
Why would they even stop us? We are hacking one game, Im sure Nintendo wouldn't sue people in a specific category.
If Nintendo tries to sue us each, and I suspect there are hundreds if not thousands of brawl hackers out there, the legal papers and lawyer fees alone would probably give them about an
extremely low amount of money, or even result in the losing money, not to mention they would lose all these people as Nintendo fans, and hopefully promoters.
they don't care.
1. They would have already taken action.
2. It makes them money.
3. Its harmless.
hacking anygame is illegal (witch I don't know why) but thats the sad truth just like the older comment why hasn't nintendo taken action maybe they hack and think its amusing too or they're too lasy 'cause they don't really care
Quote from: Roo525 on July 01, 2010, 12:13:53 AM
I think of it as:
"Hey, we bought the game, so we have the right to do what the heck we want with it."
You dont buy a cheeseburger, and the person selling it cant say you cant put ketchup on it.
You aren't buying a cheeseburger with copyright. The game is copyrighted, so technically nintendo still owns everything inside the disk. By sharing anything inside the disk modified or not is illegal. But who cares, i don't think nintendo cares all too much, its keeping their game alive.
After the game having alot of bugs, unfinished files, slightly disappointing roster and stupid unlockables no one really cares about, not to mention the 4353465677 delays they made us wait through.....and the tripping...I'd say to the people at nintendo.
they owe us >_ >
Nintendo is to busy stoping Rom hacking to think about us.
Aren't VC titles ROMs anyway?
With the small exception that, you know, they're legal for it, they're emulating many of the games we loved and cherished.
How's that for a plot twist?
Why is this thread still alive? -_-
Quote from: LookItsLink on July 19, 2010, 01:51:11 PM
Why is this thread still alive? -_-
*Shrugs Shoulders* You Got Me...
Quote from: Nuke-EM on July 19, 2010, 04:07:27 PM
Quote from: LookItsLink on July 19, 2010, 01:51:11 PM
Why is this thread still alive? -_-
*Shrugs Shoulders* You Got Me...
thats what I wanted to ask is there any solutions yet?
Quote from: PwnU555 on July 20, 2010, 12:46:25 AM
Quote from: Nuke-EM on July 19, 2010, 04:07:27 PM
Quote from: LookItsLink on July 19, 2010, 01:51:11 PM
Why is this thread still alive? -_-
*Shrugs Shoulders* You Got Me...
thats what I wanted to ask is there any solutions yet?
Stop posting here there is nothing left to discuss. Its still alive because you all keep bumping it.
Quote from: LordNOaH on July 20, 2010, 12:51:24 AM
Quote from: PwnU555 on July 20, 2010, 12:46:25 AM
Quote from: Nuke-EM on July 19, 2010, 04:07:27 PM
Quote from: LookItsLink on July 19, 2010, 01:51:11 PM
Why is this thread still alive? -_-
*Shrugs Shoulders* You Got Me...
thats what I wanted to ask is there any solutions yet?
Stop posting here there is nothing left to discuss. Its still alive because you all keep bumping it.
^This. Now the next person that bumps this thread is getting warned.