Poll
Question:
Is it okay to make the same texture as someone else?
Option 1: hell ya
votes: 33
Option 2: as long as it's better
votes: 10
Option 3: no
votes: 1
Option 4: only if you give credit
votes: 4
Option 5: only if you get permision
votes: 1
Option 6: not if theres is more than 10
votes: 8
ok is it wrong to do the same texture as another person?! i mean, what if people didn't like that texture and wanted one of their own? Wtf is wrong with people, when they see a texture like their's made by someone else? look at what happebd at ESH today, god Dairantou Glitch [censored] was all like "ass hole i already made this" and if the dude from Dairantou Glitch [censored] is reading this, your texture isn't worth 2 [censored]s anyway, it sucked major ass, and also, make your own textures recoloring someone else's dosen't make it your texture god reading that guys comment really pissed me off... >:(
Edit: Bonzai, your texture rocked, I don't care if anyone else made it first
I don't see what the big deal is. So if one guy paints a picture of a field, I'm not allowed to present my own take on it? You don't own a texture idea just because you made it first.
I generally notice that the people who say "I made this first" feel threatened because the newer texture is better than their own, so they say they did it first so they can feel superior. It's pathetic. A few months ago, someone posted a pic of a wip Chell texture that looked way better than mine (I made the first and, as far as I know, only Chell). I planned to replace mine in my game as soon as that guy released his (though he never did -- in fact I don't think he posted again -- which was disappointing).
tl;dr: People say that because a) they feel that they have some sort of ownership and/or b) they know the new one is better than theirs so they try to make the other artist look bad via ad hominem.
Nothing wrong with that...
And its always good to express your mind...And use the biggest words possible...
It's perfectly fine to do a texture someone else did. I'm not saying make another freakin Shadow, but by all means try to make what you feel is best. The only time you need to get permission is if you are editing the edited pac from another person. I did that with my PN strap loader with Fit Artifex. There was no trace of FA on it when i was done, but i couldnt access an iso or have someone give me a file, so i used theirs just to have something to edit. Even the other day, n64billy asked me if he could redo my dimentio (and i said yes). You can give credit when you use elements of another edited pac, like injured2day's nude peach FS used parts of Jose Gallardo's pipes on the top and bottom
I say heck yes, make someone else's texture.
more then often plp overeact and go out on the deep end when they see another texture they made and its better. Going back to my midna example. A few days ago I joined these new kitty korp forums and i noticed there were about 3 other midnas out there. I was pissed because they were better than mine sure but that only made me make a better one. The plp who think they own a texture obviously don't know wat competition is.
Competition is a good thing. Creating competition -- thus better textures -- was one of the main goals of that texture review site I wanted to make.
exactly vyse, actually i was gonna create a podcast sort of thing to review textures as well
people can make whatever they want but it gets annoying when there is buttloads of the same thing by 15 different people =3
Really, now.
I don't see why people make such a fuss over textures that other people make, specifically ones you've done and others are making them. That didn't stop people from making [over] 9,000 Shadow the Hedgehog textures when ASH was compatible with the blue blur... No one really cared. I don't see old ]SyntaxError[ members roaming about trolling people who made Shadow, proclaiming "HEY STOP MAKING SHADOW WE MADE HIM ALREADY COPYCATS >( ".
Texture hacking is a form of art; people draw similar stuff all the time in that sense. ]EE[ made Mewcario, SS made Dr. Mario and Roy... That didn't stop me from making my own variations of those characters.
So, if you get inspiration from someone else's work, hey, give them a little credit, too; but if you're inspired by random (and had no idea someone else made the texture), that's understandable, too. I've made plenty of textures that were made by others, without knowledge of it. Pure coincidence.
So haters, learn to shut the hell up and take it. Your texture may have been first in the market, but you shouldn't deter others from making similar variations, just because they're FANS LIKE YOU.
[censored].
Quote from: dally on June 26, 2009, 02:45:38 AM
ok is it wrong to do the same texture as another person?! i mean, what if people didn't like that texture and wanted one of their own? Wtf is wrong with people, when they see a texture like their's made by someone else? look at what happebd at ESH today, god Dairantou Glitch [censored] was all like "ass hole i already made this" and if the dude from Dairantou Glitch [censored] is reading this, your texture isn't worth 2 [censored]s anyway, it sucked major ass, and also, make your own textures recoloring someone else's dosen't make it your texture god reading that guys comment really pissed me off... >:(
Edit: Bonzai, your texture rocked, I don't care if anyone else made it first
i believe the correct name is doritos gay SAKURAI!!!!!!!! led by zerogirlfriends69.
hes in my skype calls often, really he's quiet annyoing. a few of his team members even agree with me.
also, its fine to me. don't see a problem with it.
oh damn, theres censors....i'd lol if it replaces what i just said with a picture of shadow XD
It's so nice to see people talking about me lol.
I don't intend to do stuff others have done, but there are so many places to check, it sometimes happens.
Two thing's annoyed me though:
1)So-and-so's is better.
They looked the same. They were both made of ice. I honestly liked his ice pattern better, but mine says"I'm freezing my nuts off!!"
2)ESH blah blah blah
My name is not ESH. Please, if you want to complain about my actions, don't degrade my team mates, especially BigSharkZ; he works hard just to keep his team above water.
Now for the love of everything, shut up everyone. You're putting more work in arguing than I put in my texture.
And thank you dally and everyone else who liked my work.
This is a classic case of my Joker VS FA's Joker. I did mine because i wanted to make another one, simple as that. If you dont like something, why not make something better?
lol bonzai. Conceited much? This isn't about you; this is about a general issue in the texture hacking community. Your case is just a recent example of an ongoing problem.
Woops sorry, can't read straight.
As a general rule:
1)Make what you want, but don't be a jerk about it or an egomaniac can't read straight.
2)Listen to Vyse.
Its not wrong, I had the first idea of making all the pokemon on Brawl shiny. I did only half of them but then StackSmash did all of them some better some not as good as mine. Its like they did the work for me ;P.
where's the yes unless its shadow the hedgehog button?
See "Not if there's more than 10." >.>
Quote from: ryutrigun on June 28, 2009, 06:21:14 AM
Its not wrong, I had the first idea of making all the pokemon on Brawl shiny. I did only half of them but then StackSmash did all of them some better some not as good as mine. Its like they did the work for me ;P.
That's probably the best way of looking at it.
I agree with what's been said already. Making another texture of the same thing isn't a crime. If they're the exact same quality, then it's kind of silly.
I'm going to go with answers "A", "B", and "F". Heck yes, as long as it's better, and there aren't more than 10 of the same one.
hell yes.
but... not if theres already 2. Except if they're really bad.
I wanted to do a C. Falcon - M. Bison texture, but then I found that it was already done 2 times -and they are pretty good- so I'm not gonna do it.
But I thought that posting a "meet the update (http://stacksmash.cultnet.net/?p=5498)" right in the middle of my Smash Fortress updates was pretty lame.
I read the wtf is wrong with ppl and wtf is wrong with ppl#2. I have one thing to say.....
Go down
Go down
Go down
Go down
Go down
Go down
Go down
Go down
Go down
Go down
Go down
Go down some more
Go down some more
Go down some more
Go down some more
Go down some more
Go down some more
Go down some more
Go down some more
Go down some more
Go down some more
Go down some more
Go down some more
Go down some more
Go down some more
Go down some more
Go down some more
Go down some more
Go down some more
Go down some more
Go down some more
Go down some more
Go down some more
Go down some more
Go down some more
Go down some more
Go down some more
Go down some more
Go down some more
Go down some more
Go down some more
Go down some more
Go down some more
Go down some more
Go down some more
Go down some more
Go down some more
Go down some more
Go down some more
Go down some more
Go down some more
Milk is awesome =D
Hell yeah, milk IS awesome.
...why is everyone posting random things In my wtf's? And i would like it if the admins would stop posting in Wtf #2...
Quote from: dally on July 19, 2009, 01:32:24 AM
...why is everyone posting random things In my wtf's? And i would like it if the admins would stop posting in Wtf #2...
like this?
(http://i645.photobucket.com/albums/uu179/IndieSpice510/inb4lock.gif)
i can see it coming
that made me roflmao
Dally, you can't expect people to take these topic seriously. Your posting about issues that people barely give a [censored] about.
yea, when people read it they "say wtf!?"
I don't expect ppl to take them seriously, It just irritates me how much power the admins have, lol and about the random things, It just makes me wonder "huh, I wish ppl would put theese many posts in my texture thread"
We're admins, of course we have power. Would you rather we be serious and no fun all the time? I'd be glad the admins have a sense of humor... But that's just me.
Well admins have that much power because they are admins. They can do anything they want to the forum, technically they are gods (over the forums).
DAMN YOU VYSE, it wouldn't let me post coz you were posting :mk:
Hahahahahahahahaha...
WOO
well... I guess your right guys, and ya you guys do have a good sense of humor XD
Awwww. Who eat my cookies? I went to the bathroom and then they are gone.... >.<
Oh [censored]. My milk.(no homo) Where is it?
crap you milk! i had to go through that with my DSi! it was still spamalicious
What kind of cookies? Oreos? Chips Ahoy!? Fig Newtons?
Anyway, on topic, there's nothing wrong with others making the same char./stage texture as others, as it creates competition. I made a Don Patchi texture for Kirby a while back, but StackSmash released theirs before i released mine, and theirs was much better than mine. That's alright with me, though, as the competition keeps me motivated.
Quote from: Midnite•Shaymin on July 19, 2009, 08:00:38 PM
What kind of cookies? Oreos? Chips Ahoy!? Fig Newtons?
Oh IDK..................(Slowly reaches Midnight's cookie bag)
And I like your textures(grabs cookies)
(Runs home to wife and feeds children.
MilkaholicX Jr.(Oldest son)
Milk Lynn X.(youngest daughter)
lolololol. take that midnight.(Sleeps and never wakes because midnight poisened the cookies) Mrs. Milk helps her husband and revives him and then they go to the bedroom and...........................(close your eyes children.)
(http://media.comicvine.com/uploads/0/6955/803205-holy_facepalm_super.jpg)
lulz
Lmfao.
Milk I hid your milk in my fridge...
(http://th05.deviantart.net/fs46/300W/f/2009/200/9/d/Cat_with_a_Butterknife_by_Plasmakirby1.jpg)
Quote from: Tennet on July 19, 2009, 10:44:55 PM
Milk I hid your milk in my fridge...
How dare you...............
(gets Milk's friends and breaks in Tennet's house. Steals milk back from tennet. Goes home and drinks milk.)
Hmmmm. This milk tastes funny
(soon realizes that it's not milk.)
Holy [censored].
(Drops in the false milk or white liquid)
Honey(Milk's wife, Milka X), help me..
(Slowly dies in the corner and goes in a fetal postion)
Dam tennet
(slowly crawls to the fridge and reaches for the cake. But wife closes the door and Milk dies. Milka X saves her husband. And they go to the other room and they start ******* each other and starts to **** his ****. Milk's friend walks into the house and sees the milk. He drinks it and tastes the ***** of Tennet.)
Dam you tennet!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
(He slowly dies)
The End.
...
...
why the ...
Dude... the clear container...not the one with the skull...
Quote from: Tennet on July 20, 2009, 01:41:32 PM
Dude... the clear container...not the one with the skull...
Wha?
0.o
IM JUST OUR FRIENDLY NEIGHBORHOOD CIDER MAN!
or Mr. Rogers... I want YOU for My neighborhood!
who delete my long and spamtastic message? lol. i think I know why you deleted
WHO DARE DELETE SUCH AWESOME SPAM!?!?
Don't look at me, look at someone else. >.>
Quote from: Shadow on July 21, 2009, 08:41:57 PM
Don't look at me, look at someone else. >.>
*Looks at Marcov*
Quote from: Shadow on July 21, 2009, 08:41:57 PM
Don't look at me, look at someone else. >.>
you should have made this emoticon
(o_o)> (0.0;)
OOT!
How to spell your name (aloud) to a person
S as in Shadow
H as in Hey, its Shadow
A as in Ahhh. It the great Shadow.
D as in Dont open the door. (its shadow)
O as in Oh my god. it is shadow
W as in Wow. Im meeting Shadow.
P as in PlasmaKirby
L as in Look! PlasmaKirby
A as in Ahhhh. Its PlasmaKirby
S as in Shhh. Its PlasmaKirby
M as in My god. What happened to PlasmaKirby
A as in Apple?
K as in Kindergarden?
I as in I love PlasmaKirby
R as in Rough PlasmaKirby
B as in Be quiet. Its PlasmaKirby
Y as in Yes. I want to marry PlasmaKirby
M as in MilkaholicX
I as in I want to **** MilkaholicX
L as in Look at that sexy MilkaholicX
K as in Kindergarten and PlasmaKirby belong woith each other.
A as in Ahhh. I love MilkaholicX
H as in helloo MilkaholicX
O as in Oh. I took your milk (beats him up)
L as in Look. MilkaholicX
I as in I want to have *** with MilkaholicX
C as in Can you help me took off my clothes, MilkaholicX
X as in X_X
Ohai Milk =D
oh oh tee
T as in Tennet
E as in, Ew, it's Tennet
N as in Nobody likes Tennet
N as in No Tennets allowed
E as in Everyone hate Tennet
T as in Taken captive by MilkaholicX
(it wasn't hateful intentionally. it was the only way i could get it to work. the last line was intentional though XD)
V as in VILE
I as in I am VILE
L as in Lick my balls
E as in Eat my [censored]
I dont see what the big deal is,but mostly if the old one suck and the new one is better
I think the creator needs to give the original credit.
D as in Deep in thought about Dally
A as in absolutley, I would love to serve Dally
L as in let Dally have his rest before getting near him
L as in lollipop lollipop oh la la lolipop
Y as in Why should Dally listen to you?
From reading the last few posts, I don't even know what this topic is about anymore.
Quote from: OizenX on August 08, 2009, 04:15:21 PM
From reading the last few posts, I don't even know what this topic is about anymore.
Haha. This became a fun thread.....
this thread is basicly a complete off topic thread to discuss anything now... but dont lock it
I wont lock it.