I see what you're trying to do there, and I think it would still look pretty good if you could get the outline to look like pink yarn and the rest to look like some other kind of fabric. Don't give up!
It does look like yarn. I used the exact yarn texture from a picture.
This in the BrawlVault yet? I would help but sadly I can't texture hack. I want this texture ASAP!
Click the picture in my first post to go to it.