Brawl Vault Problems, Updates, and Suggestions

[Vyse]

Why isn't it up to the creator of the hack to require permission or not

The basis for this entire community is not asking Nintendo for permission to modify their stuff.

It would be hypocritical to require permission to use something that is, on some level, stolen.

[??_?]

Hmm, that makes no sense at all. Can someone please ask nintendo for permission so you can change it back?

[Miacis]

The original author is still free to ask for a collab/credit or to ask for a offensive hack to be removed, anyways.
It's just that it's not really a mandatory part of editing anyone's hack anymore.

It's just that there just aren't enough cases where a collab/credit/friendly arrangement can't solve the issue, anymore.

[??_?]

That makes more sense for sure.  I guess my question is, can the original creator request it's removal despite not needing permission?

[Don Jon Bravo]

So does this guy need to collab Nano for the "Minor edits"
Yes or No?

[POKE MASTER]

So does this guy need to collab Nano for the "Minor edits"
Yes or No?

I'd have called those "minuscule edits*..... 0.0

[Victory Badguy]

So does this guy need to collab Nano for the "Minor edits"
Yes or No?

According to the rules, yes.  Minor edits need collaboration (though I agree that those "edits" seem less than minor).

Odd that he collab'd Velen but didn't collab Nano.

[Don Jon Bravo]

I'd have called those "minuscule edits*..... 0.0

lol

According to the rules, yes.  Minor edits need collaboration (though I agree that those "edits" seem less than minor).

Odd that he collab'd Velen but didn't collab Nano.

yea and he took velens work out of the model too
lol

anyways i dont like "complaining" about stuff but when i saw this hack, I just saw it as: stolen
idk why though
maybe the name of the hack threw me off

[Victory Badguy]

anyways i dont like "complaining" about stuff but when i saw this hack, I just saw it as: stolen
idk why though
maybe the name of the hack threw me off

Well, it's not stolen because he did give credit.  He just didn't give the right kind of credit.  Honestly though there's a ton of hacks on the Vault that are like this one and the makers didn't collab the original makers, so I don't think this is a big issue or anything.  I mean, it'd be great if he changed it, but it's no priority or anything, at least in opinion.

[POKE MASTER]

http://forums.kc-mm.com/Gallery/BrawlView.php?Number=29295

Sorry I made a fail report.......kinda ^^^

[Victory Badguy]

http://forums.kc-mm.com/Gallery/BrawlView.php?Number=29295

Sorry I made a fail report.......kinda ^^^

Don't worry.  I replaced it with my own. :P

[Miacis]

That makes more sense for sure.  I guess my question is, can the original creator request it's removal despite not needing permission?

To the hacker who edited his work? Yes, he can ask him to delete it, of course. Heck, if he was collabbed, I'm pretty sure he can delete it by himself too.
Doesn't mean the other guy will be forced to accept the request, though.

According to the rules, yes.  Minor edits need collaboration (though I agree that those "edits" seem less than minor).

Odd that he collab'd Velen but didn't collab Nano.

Whut?

Minor edits to others' work are allowed to an extent. For example, if you create a night/rain/snow version of someone's stage or change a character's shirt from green to blue and want to post it on the Vault, you have to collaborate the creator of the original hack.

[mnsg]

I can't seem to access the Brawl Vault at all lately.  Every time I try, I always end up getting the following link now...

https://www.paypalobjects.com/Gallery/BrawlView.php

Is this some sort of joke?  I mean, if everyone else is getting on the Brawl Vault okay, why am I not?

Edit: New discovery.  It seems that if I access the Brawl Vault, via, my vault ID, I get on without any problems.  Therefore, the problem seems to only occur with the following link alone...

http://forums.kc-mm.com/Gallery/BrawlView.php

[Victory Badguy]

Whut?

Minor edits to others' work are allowed to an extent. For example, if you create a night/rain/snow version of someone's stage or change a character's shirt from green to blue and want to post it on the Vault, you have to collaborate the creator of the original hack.

Yeah, that's the rules I was going off of when I said that.  Am I misinterpreting it?  It says minor edits need collaboration, so that's what I said.

Is it different now?  I'd like to know before I go around saying anything else here.

[Miacis]

I can't seem to access the Brawl Vault at all lately.  Every time I try, I always end up getting the following link now...

https://www.paypalobjects.com/Gallery/BrawlView.php

Is this some sort of joke?  I mean, if everyone else is getting on the Brawl Vault okay, why am I not?

I don't really see how a joke like that would be remotely funny, so it may be a problem on your own computer.

Try and clear your cache and cookies, see if it removes that stuff?

Yeah, that's the rules I was going off of when I said that.  Am I misinterpreting it?  It says minor edits need collaboration, so that's what I said.

Is it different now?  I'd like to know before I go around saying anything else here.

I ... uh ... sorry, I think I just misread what you were saying. Disregard that post from earlier. ^^'