Brawl Vault Problems, Updates, and Suggestions

[✿Zelia✿]

Lol k :P

Invalid Report #1

As long their is one picture working, it's okay.

Invalid Report #2

Well he can create a .pcs, but then again, I think he didn't know that, but it still works anyways, because the file is full of .pacs.

Invalid Report #3

As long as their is a stage, it's okay, I believe.

Invalid Report #4

The pictures are fine.

Invalid Report #5

If one pic is working, then it's fine.

[SSJ Is Clueless!]

oooh yah sorry that first one was mine (along time ago) i was a noob

[Infernape]

holy crap miacis dat stars are sick.

[Puraidou]

Invalid Report #3

As long as their is a stage, it's okay, I believe.

No. The stage has to be the one in the pics and name, if it's not then it's a legit report.

Fixed the other 4

[Ӄit ßallarɖ]

http://forums.kc-mm.com/Gallery/BrawlView.php?Number=25933

How'ed this not only get by everyone, but also have over 100 downloads in a day?

[Puraidou]

http://forums.kc-mm.com/Gallery/BrawlView.php?Number=25933

How'ed this not only get by everyone, but also have over 100 downloads in a day?

This has been posted before and like Miacis said "We won't delete these unless someone included in the pack wants it removed".

[SJS]

Well you can't exactly expect hack creators to constantly be on the lookout for their stuff being used without permission. Putting the contents of your SD card in a RAR and uploading it essentially takes no effort.

[_Data_Drain_]

Well you can't exactly expect hack creators to constantly be on the lookout for their stuff being used without permission. Putting the contents of your SD card in a RAR and uploading it essentially takes no effort.

Very true. Since most of them may not always be able to get on.

Like DO, he RARELY goes on here. So of course it would slip passed him... I'd say remove it.

[Miacis]

Well you can't exactly expect hack creators to constantly be on the lookout for their stuff being used without permission. Putting the contents of your SD card in a RAR and uploading it essentially takes no effort.

However, we do not expect BV Staff to know beforehand if the permissions were gotten or not. Only the original author of the hack knows if the hack was authorized or not. Taking things down because "it looks like he didn't get permission but actually I don't really know" is as close to arbitrary incompetence as anyone can get.

The base idea is: if the hack creators care about nobody "stealing" their download, they can afford to browse the Vault once in a while to check for plagiarism. If they don't care, then no need to play hard cops for them. We've been saying that ever since the creation of the plagiarism rule.

If the BV staff feels like being zealous, they can just go and ask every single author if they did grant permission. If not, then don't take the freagin' thing down. Falsely censoring something something based on its looks is much worse than having a hack pack "stealing" a hundreds or so downloads.

Also, I suggested a compromise about Hack Packs, that went utterly disregarded:
http://forums.kc-mm.com/index.php?topic=2555.msg884041#msg884041

[Puraidou]

Well you can't exactly expect hack creators to constantly be on the lookout for their stuff being used without permission. Putting the contents of your SD card in a RAR and uploading it essentially takes no effort.

True, but it's not our job to check if the author granted permission or not. If they don't want it to be used, then either make it extremely easy to see or browse the BV to see if someone uses your stuff or not.

Like DO, he RARELY goes on here. So of course it would slip passed him... I'd say remove it.

If he doesn't want stuff used, have him browse the BV himself. We won't whiteknight on his behalf if we don't know if the guy has permission or not.

http://forums.kc-mm.com/index.php?topic=2555.msg884041#msg884041

In the case of posting "Hack Mega Packs", if crediting or collabing every author proves too difficult, the uploader may add a text file in the pack, referencing the authors of all the hacks included and, if possible, a link to their BrawlVault.
If an author wasn't credited in that text file and asks for his name to be added, the uploader of the "Mega Pack" needs to add him in ASAP.

Seems like a legit compromise to me.

[Segtendo]

Very true. Since most of them may not always be able to get on.

Like DO, he RARELY goes on here. So of course it would slip passed him... I'd say remove it.

Well, he did list a few people who are active, like KJP, SDo0m, MarioDK...
We could ask them if they want it removed.

Also, I suggested a compromise about Hack Packs, that went utterly disregarded:
http://forums.kc-mm.com/index.php?topic=2555.msg884041#msg884041

I saw it. I just didn't say anything about it >.<
I guess a TXT file could suffice...

[BlueBrain]

http://forums.kc-mm.com/Gallery/BrawlView.php?Number=25962

invalid report?
i mean, it is a PSA that edits the sounds, how do u make pics from sounds???
xD

[Infernape]

http://forums.kc-mm.com/Gallery/BrawlView.php?Number=25962

invalid report?
i mean, it is a PSA that edits the sounds, how do u make pics from sounds???
xD

Well it needs to be more specific, like could you make a video.

[Segtendo]

Well it needs to be more specific, like could you make a video.

I was actually thinking that he could do this.

[Infernape]

Well here: http://forums.kc-mm.com/Gallery/BrawlView.php?Number=25648
does it need pics? and i think that is invalid report.