Brawl Vault Problems, Updates, and Suggestions

[Puraidou]

Hello,

This hack include one of my texture hack parts: http://forums.kc-mm.com/Gallery/BrawlView.php?Number=28748

and mine: http://forums.kc-mm.com/Gallery/BrawlView.php?Number=25426

(he edited a bit but we can see where most parts come from.. Screenshot of his textures and mine at the bottom..)


I've reported to prevent the author and reply me  that everything is him, this is an original idea and he even threatened to report me.. seriously ?!

I want to trust him, but I can't.. it's so obvious and make me a little bit angry..

Look... the ''difference'' of his and mine...

Sorry but you are not allowed to view spoiler contents.

His Link is an import from Skyward Sword, so textures looks different but the parts I'm showing you are the same with a little edit... We can also see on the second and third image the détails from original Brawl Link (I had saved them for my hack and be ''chance'' are on his Skyward Sword Link)..  I've a tip to ''enlarge'' small textures from others game, I've use that for my Majora Textures Hacks and I suppose he doesn't know how to do.

If this proof is not enough for you, just DL these hack and compare yourself... also look our upload date to définitively  know which one of us steals each other.

Thanks... and sorry if I don't know how to correctly write in English..

I'm so confused...  :srs:

1st pic seems to be mirrored. 2nd pic is just a filter thrown over it. 3rd pic is a bigger edit then the rest but still.. This looks stolen to me.. Can anyone else from the BV Staff shed their opinion on it?

[BBreon]

He doesn't stole whole of my hack but some parts, the third pics is the same case as second, with a rotation (adaptation), because Brawl Link and Skyward Sword Link (import) are different (Textures and UV).

What the problem to ask a permission to do that.. He says he's a texture master, doesn't he seem to know how long texture hacking take..?

I'm not an expert but I'm proud about my textures and it hurts me to see someone to take my work without asking me anything..

[✿Zelia✿]

1st pic seems to be mirrored. 2nd pic is just a filter thrown over it. 3rd pic is a bigger edit then the rest but still.. This looks stolen to me.. Can anyone else from the BV Staff shed their opinion on it?

Yeah am thinking that it's stolen as well. :/

[PAVGN]

FALSE REPORT

http://forums.kc-mm.com/Gallery/BrawlView.php?Number=28773

Screenshot Links aren't dead.

Why hasn't this false report been removed yet?

[Victory Badguy]

Why hasn't this false report been removed yet?

Fixed.  Sorry for the delay.

1st pic seems to be mirrored. 2nd pic is just a filter thrown over it. 3rd pic is a bigger edit then the rest but still.. This looks stolen to me.. Can anyone else from the BV Staff shed their opinion on it?

Yeah, it looks stolen to me.  Even if he didn't use all of the original textures, the second one is clearly plagiarized.

[Chaos_Knight]

http://forums.kc-mm.com/Gallery/BrawlView.php?Number=28783

Someone remove this for me. Every person has their own right to make a hack even if it exists right? And I'm going to be honest, I didn't know the blue one looked so similar to the reporter. o.o

[PAVGN]

http://forums.kc-mm.com/Gallery/BrawlView.php?Number=28783

Someone remove this for me. Every person has their own right to make a hack even if it exists right? And I'm going to be honest, I didn't know the blue one looked so similar to the reporter. o.o

You can remove reports on your own hacks. :notimp:

[Albafika]

Hello,

This hack include one of my texture hack parts: http://forums.kc-mm.com/Gallery/BrawlView.php?Number=28748

and mine: http://forums.kc-mm.com/Gallery/BrawlView.php?Number=25426

(he edited a bit but we can see where most parts come from.. Screenshot of his textures and mine at the bottom..)


I've reported to prevent the author and reply me  that everything is him, this is an original idea and he even threatened to report me.. seriously ?!

I want to trust him, but I can't.. it's so obvious and make me a little bit angry..

Look... the ''difference'' of his and mine...

Sorry but you are not allowed to view spoiler contents.

His Link is an import from Skyward Sword, so textures looks different but the parts I'm showing you are the same with a little edit... We can also see on the second and third image the détails from original Brawl Link (I had saved them for my hack and be ''chance'' are on his Skyward Sword Link)..  I've a tip to ''enlarge'' small textures from others game, I've use that for my Majora Textures Hacks and I suppose he doesn't know how to do.

If this proof is not enough for you, just DL these hack and compare yourself... also look our upload date to définitively  know which one of us steals each other.

Thanks... and sorry if I don't know how to correctly write in English..

I'm so confused...  :srs:

I'll handle this.

His hack has been deleted. You're not the first person he's stolen a texture from. He can re-submit it though, so long as proper credit is given to whoever asks him to give it with proof, like you did.

[Segtendo]

About this guy...
http://forums.kc-mm.com/Gallery/BrawlView.php?Number=28787
I reported this guy last night cuz he hasn't given proper credit for the models he used. However, he ignored the report. I'd keep a watch on this guy.

[Albafika]

And that's something to be posted on the section...

[Segtendo]

<.>
Fine.

[Victory Badguy]

Would someone be willing to help me out with something?  I've been trying to see if that Saria hack that's been uploaded and reported a bunch of times recently is really plagiarized.

The models are clearly different:

Sorry but you are not allowed to view spoiler contents.

But many of the textures are very similar or identical.  I'm not sure if the textures were stolen or if they just used the same source for their textures without knowing.

[Segtendo]

Would someone be willing to help me out with something?  I've been trying to see if that Saria hack that's been uploaded and reported a bunch of times recently is really plagiarized.

The models are clearly different:

Sorry but you are not allowed to view spoiler contents.

But many of the textures are very similar or identical.  I'm not sure if the textures were stolen or if they just used the same source for their textures without knowing.

I think we found the right model on MSN.
http://forums.kc-mm.com/Gallery/BrawlView.php?Number=15516

[Victory Badguy]

I think we found the right model on MSN.
http://forums.kc-mm.com/Gallery/BrawlView.php?Number=15516

OK yeah, it's the same as that one.

Edit:  Actually, it seems like there are some minor differences with the textures, most notably with the eyes.  Still 90% Black Boo's work though

[Segtendo]

Good. I reported him 3 times, Beyond once. He clearly ignored our reports.