Brawl Vault Problems, Updates, and Suggestions

[Anivernage]

Forgot to add in my last post, I'm positive ds22 didn't submit that before me; I checked the sfx hack list for any JP Ike sawnds / brsars, and there were none. Apparently he either didn't bother to check, or he noticed mine and submitted it anyway. For all I know, he could have just downloaded my hack and renamed it.

lol man, he never makes that >_>
if talking about a noob its more % of that noob reupload yours, but i dont think ds22 do that.

There can be many versions of the same hack, look at shadow. he has many versions of the same model.

[SonicBrawler]

Forgot to add in my last post, I'm positive ds22 didn't submit that before me; I checked the sfx hack list for any JP Ike sawnds / brsars, and there were none. Apparently he either didn't bother to check, or he noticed mine and submitted it anyway. For all I know, he could have just downloaded my hack and renamed it.

[spoiler]

I highly highly highly doubt that ds22 would take your stuff and reuplaod it. and there can be multiple version/uploads of a hack. look at shaderp.

[??_?]

Yea. Didn't re-read it.

Yea. I think it should be added to the first post.

...why? He was just making a suggestion, and he's the first person to have made it.

[JirachiMaster]

I highly highly highly doubt that ds22 would take your stuff and reuplaod it. and there can be multiple version/uploads of a hack. look at shaderp.

This isn't a simple texture or even a remake of one, it's a sound pack. They all have the exact same wavs in them as mine. So you're saying you would be okay with me taking some of your hacks, changing their names and reuploading them?

[SonicBrawler]

This isn't a simple texture or even a remake of one, it's a sound pack. They all have the exact same wavs in them as mine. So you're saying you would be okay with me taking some of your hacks, changing their names and reuploading them?

uhm, what? if they are both the same hack, of course they have the same waves.

[JirachiMaster]

uhm, what? if they are both the same hack, of course they have the same waves.

That's what I'm saying. He uploaded the same god damned thing as me. What's the point of having 2 of the exact same sound pack on the site?

[SonicBrawler]

That's what I'm saying. He uploaded the same god damned thing as me. What's the point of having 2 of the exact same sound pack on the site?

> 2 of the exact same
> millions of shadow on the vault

[Anivernage]

That's what I'm saying. He uploaded the same god damned thing as me. What's the point of having 2 of the exact same sound pack on the site?

But both take them from brawl jpn iso of course will have the ******* same sounds!!!

Im sure he make his first r)

> 2 of the exact same
> millions of shadow on the vault

This^

[JirachiMaster]

But both take them from brawl jpn iso of course will have the ******* same sounds!!! Im sure he make his first r) This^

You obviously haven't read my other posts.

[Anivernage]

You obviously haven't read my other posts.

Well my point is theres no need to fight for this.

Like SB says there are many shadows and noone is claming their hack as original.

Just relax, both make their version, now peace.
He worked on sooo much things including adding texture slots, im sure he never steals hacks man.

[SJS]

There is no plagiarism issue here. Both audio hacks were compiled from the same source, so I don't see what the problem is if both JirachiMaster and ds22's SFX replacements stay on the Vault. We do the same if two modelers rig the same model. Quit making this non-issue into a big deal by throwing around baseless accusations.

[JirachiMaster]

There is no plagiarism issue here. Both audio hacks were compiled from the same source, so I don't see what the problem is if both JirachiMaster and ds22's SFX replacements stay on the Vault. We do the same if two modelers rig the same model. Quit making this non-issue into a big deal by throwing around baseless accusations.

Initially I didn't say he plagiarised, I said that it was a possibility. I just didn't know that submitting the same sfx or textures was allowed.

[Puraidou]

ds22 is a Global Moderator, he doesn't steal hacks.

There is no plagiarism issue here. Both audio hacks were compiled from the same source, so I don't see what the problem is if both JirachiMaster and ds22's SFX replacements stay on the Vault. We do the same if two modelers rig the same model. Quit making this non-issue into a big deal by throwing around baseless accusations.

^This.

[Segtendo]

...why? He was just making a suggestion, and he's the first person to have made it.

I believe many people in this thread  have suggested the ability to show "recently edited" hacks in the Vault.

[SJS]

Initially I didn't say he plagiarised, I said that it was a possibility. I just didn't know that submitting the same sfx or textures was allowed.

Duplicates are allowed if the same base is used, or if the same idea is trying to be conveyed. Taking someone's existing mod and reuploading it with no changes is not allowed. The BRSTM section is an extreme and chaotic example of duplicates using the same base being uploaded.