Brawl Vault Problems, Updates, and Suggestions

[KingJigglypuff]

Is it SERIOUSLY a simple .REL port? I don't wanna have this guy restricted forever if it's not.

Yes. It is a .rel port. I downloaded it to make sure, and I can confirm that it is a .rel port.

[Victory Badguy]

The description says that some moves were fixed.  Now, does this mean that they originally didn't work or they did but not for the port without the fix?  I mean, if they actually updated the hack then a case could be made for it not being blatant theft.

[SonicBrawler]

are we not allowed to post .rel ports anymore? i thought if we credit the people we can post it.

The description says that some moves were fixed.  Now, does this mean that they originally didn't work or they did but not for the port without the fix?  I mean, if they actually updated the hack then a case could be made for it not being blatant theft.

it sounds like a lot of hooplah it was edited just for the .rel port

[Victory Badguy]

are we not allowed to post .rel ports anymore? i thought if we credit the people we can post it.

It's being debated.  I'm not quite sure if any consensus has been reached, but it seems like most people are leaning towards "no ports".

[KingJigglypuff]

The description says that some moves were fixed.  Now, does this mean that they originally didn't work or they did but not for the port without the fix?  I mean, if they actually updated the hack then a case could be made for it not being blatant theft.

Yes, you are right. And the uploader did change a few moves...You can now claim my post as invalid...

[SonicBrawler]

i see. I think that ports shoudl eb released if

a) the person gets credit from everyone
b) the person reports teh gltcihes

[Anonymous]

are we not allowed to post .rel ports anymore? i thought if we credit the people we can post it.
it sounds like a lot of hooplah it was edited just for the .rel port

This is how I feel with .rels

    o THIS INCLUDES MINOR EDITS TO OTHERS' WORK. If you copy what someone has written and superficially change a few words, it's still plagiarism; the same concept applies here. For example, creating a night/rain/snow version of someone's stage or changing a character's shirt from green to blue and releasing it on your own is plagiarism. If you want edits like this to be public, you may send screenshots and a download link to the creator and let him decide if he would like to upload it to his Vault, with him crediting you instead of you crediting him for everything but the five minutes of work you put into your edit.•Make sure you have working preview pictures when submitting your creation. In-game pictures are not strictly necessary, but make sure your previews clearly show the majority of your changes. People who repeatedly submit things without working previews will be temporarily banned from submitting.
   

Now, wouldn't .rel ports go under that catagory? If I recall, someone here mentioned that .rels are pretty easy to do. (assuming there aren't floating points used.) basically, I think it should be opposite if what's up there at the top of this post.

[Victory Badguy]

Yes, you are right. And the uploader did change a few moves...You can now claim my post as invalid...

Oh, so it is different?  Well, that clears things up.  Guess it's OK.

[Sanada]

??? I don't understand? So rel ports are allowed even if small edits are made (like a move change?) ?

[Albafika]

We established straight .REL ports were forbidden. This guy did more than just .REL porting, so it seems, so it's staying.

It needs no more discussion.

??? I don't understand? So rel ports are allowed even if small edits are made (like a move change?) ?

No one has the patience to count the amount of edits made.

[Segtendo]

That seems like it would make sense. I agree with your logic, Wolfric.

[Chaos_Knight]

Ok is it me or does anyone else have a problem when browsing hacks?

I keep getting a Problem: Unknown

[Don Jon Bravo]

i was getting those but their gone atm

[crazytail11]

Ok is it me or does anyone else have a problem when browsing hacks?

I keep getting a Problem: Unknown

I'm getting that problem too :/

[nernerman]

yes I am getting that too